In Red Dead Redemption 2, the small camp tasks often reveal interesting character dynamics and can lead to helpful rewards. Susan Grimshaw’s request for herbs isn’t just a simple fetch quest—it hints at her subtle defiance against camp cook Mr. Pearson. Completing this task offers a neat handy item and insight into the camp’s daily life.
In Red Dead Redemption 2, there’s a camp item request where Susan Grimshaw asks you to find some herbs for seasoning, which include Wild Mint, Creeping Thyme, or Oregano. 2x of any of them would be enough. In return, she leaves you a Potent Miracle Tonic by your tent. Let’s see how to fulfill her herbs request.
To get Susan’s request underway, you need to be around the camp during the gang’s daytime activities. Susan tends to approach Arthur during mid-morning or afternoon hours, so avoid late nights or early dawn. She’ll ask for you to bring her some herbs for seasoning, whispering that Pearson shouldn’t find out about it, which adds a bit of camp intrigue to the task.
To trigger Susan Grimshaw’s camp item request, you just need to be hanging around in the camp where the gang’s doing their daily stuff. It shouldn’t be late at night or very early in the morning, as Susan might not be available. Anyhow, at some point, Susan approaches Arthur and says that if he runs into any herbs for seasoning during his travels, it would be nice to bring her some.
She doesn’t want Mr. Pearson to know anything about that since he’s the gang’s cook and all. So, these herbs include Wild Mint, Creeping Thyme, or Oregano, 2x of which should satisfy her.
Susan Herbs Location in RDR2
Finding the herbs Susan wants isn’t a wild goose chase. Just south of your base at Horseshoe Overlook lies Limpany, a burned-down town scattered with Wild Mint plants. This spot is also great for other loot, including gold bars if you keep an eye out. Collect two of any herb—Wild Mint, Creeping Thyme, or Oregano—and you’re set to return to camp.
How to Give Susan Herbs
Once you have the herbs, find Susan in the camp and interact with her to complete the request. Choose the option to give the herbs, and you’ll hear her joking about sneaking them into Pearson’s cooking when he’s not looking. It’s a small moment that adds flavor to the camp’s personality beyond just the quest itself.
RDR2 Susan Request Reward
After handing over the herbs, don’t expect instant thanks. Wait a day or two in-game, then check your tent back at camp. Susan leaves a Potent Miracle Tonic waiting, a valuable item that fully replenishes your Health, Stamina, and Dead Eye while giving a nice boost to all three. It’s a reward worth the small effort, especially for those who rely on these meters in combat and exploration.
RDR2
- Release Date
- October 26, 2018
- ESRB
- M for Mature 17+ (Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language, and Use of Drugs and Alcohol)
- Developer(s)
- Rockstar Games
- Publisher(s)
- Rockstar Games